Monika Brandmeier is a sculptor who sometimes makes still photographs and videos. Because she is trained to priviledge a consideration of how three-dimensional objects are perceived in space, in her photographic works the flatness of the picture surface and the four corners of the frame (or screen) are not treated as a benign pre-conditions. Instead, she uses flatness and framing—conventions that are so fundamental to photography that we barely notice them any more—as her conceptual starting point by not allowing them to remain invisible.
Brandmeier’s work is very much about the process of photographing, and about the difference between perceiving something in real time and space and looking at its image in a four-cornered frame at a later point in time.
Brandmeier’s work is very much about the process of photographing, and about the difference between perceiving something in real time and space and looking at its image in a four-cornered frame at a later point in time. In her works Formatting Blick/Formatting Views (2004), Drei Antworten auf zwei Fragen/Three Answers to Two Questions (2000), and Immer über dasselbe stolpern/Always Tripping Over the Same Thing (2001), Brandmeier shoots the same objects from various angles and distances. The images that comprise these works are very different from one another, effectively illustrating that photographs are highly selective interpretations of reality. By focusing her camera on one thing from various points-of-view Brandmeier also allows the viewer to see “beyond the frames.” In other words, one picture negates the constraint of the frame in another, by offering information that is “cut off” by its edge.
Very interested in the spatial relationships between cameras, the objects they record, and viewers of photographs, Brandmeier methodically explores the mechanisms of photographic illusion using simple props. Glass beakers, cardboard, wooden palettes, wire, and paper are typical of the materials she uses to construct her photographic tableaus. The “use value” of most of these items in the real world is to build things or bind things together — their identity is malleable and continually morphed. Similarly, our perception, or reading, of Brandmeier’s images is meant to remain unfixed and open to possibility and fluxuation.
Brandmeier uses line, form, and reflection to layer, confuse, and emphasize the sense of space in her images.
Brandmeier uses line, form, and reflection to layer, confuse, and emphasize the sense of space in her images. In her video Löffel/Spoon (2003), for example, a spoon rotates slowly and reflects an image of the artist and her video camera each time it rotates in front of the lens. When the side of the spoon is in view, the image of the artist disappears and the viewer’s attention shifts to space beyond the spoon captured by the camera, in this case the view out of the studio window. The outdoors can also be seen in the architecture that fills up the space surrounding the spoon in the four corners of the video screen. Our sense of space is in constant flux, much like it is in reality. The cycling of the imagery invites the viewer to mentally jump from one spatial “layer” to another, and by extension to become aware of his or her own position in relation to the art object.
“One aspect in many of my works is the idea of space as a dynamic medium, an empty volume that can be loaded with connections, where our physical movement and the direction of our gaze create imaginary lines,” explains Brandmeier.
Immer über dasselbe stolpern/Always Tripping Over the Same Thing is about duration and the process of looking at, reading, and remembering images. In this series Brandmeier discourages a linear reading from left to right by changing the third picture’s format from black-and-white to color and by repeating a picture. The repeated picture has the effect of “tripping” the viewer, raising the question of whether we are more likely to mentally “stumble” on something we see again than on something we see for the first time.
The four small corner-shaped pieces in Formatting Blick/Formatting Views imitate the frame indicators one sees when looking through a camera’s viewfinder. The photographs are taken from three distinct vantage points. Consequently, in each picture the objects appear to have radically shifted position. For Brandmeier, this proves that the act of photographing is a “projection,” a process that does not record a scene as it is, but rather “projects” the technical conditions of the camera, the four corners of the frame, and the aesthetic choices of the photographer onto it in the final image.
By reconstructing spatial relationships the viewer is prompted to imagine space and time beyond the flatness and frames of photographic images.
The series Drei Antworten auf zwei Fragen/Three Answers to Two Questions was photographed near the Polish town of Bydgoszcz. The motif is an abandoned architectural shell built in a field. The building, with its gaps of unglazed windows and empty doorways, forms a structure that has an open flow between its spatial interior and the outdoor landscape. During the course of her photographic “inspection,” as she calls it, Brandmeier adds temporary props and half-formed sentences that conceptually correspond to the architecture that is also artificial and ill-defined. Ultimately these images operate on three levels by investigating: how the props relate to the original structure; how the building’s doorways and windows relate to the frame of the photograph; and how the different vantage points of the camera and multiple images significantly change the appearance of the subject matter from one picture to the next.
By reconstructing spatial relationships the viewer is prompted to imagine space and time beyond the flatness and frames of photographic images. Ultimately, Brandmeier’s thought-provoking work confronts us with both our expectations of what defines a medium, and the workings of our own perception.
—Karen Irvine, Curator